Quote of the day

"Allusion through similarity of form is, I have discovered, a marvelously rich vein of self-reference, but unfortunately this article is too short to contain a full proof of that discovery."
—Douglas Hofstadter, Metamagical Themas

Books of Lost Swords Review

The Books of Lost Swords, Saberhagen. No. Prompted by recent reading, I re-read all eight of the Lost Swords books. I get the feeling Fred gave up about mid-way through (probably around the Sherlock Holmes hommage), and by the last couple wanted to kill the series so badly that he ignored the previous rules by which the Swords had operated. My disappointment with the tying up of loose ends in this series was similar to my disappointment with Ardneh’s Sword, though this one didn’t so much end up contradicting existing canon (Sword rules notwithstanding) as leaving me thinking "Really? That’s the best you can do with an abiding enigma?" Quite unsatisfying.

Self-Made Man Review

Self-Made Man, Vincent. No. This was a book-club obligation, a book I would not likely have read voluntarily (and I ended up reading only one of the sections). Between the author’s assumptions, generalizations, and overall unwillingness to maintain a coherent position, the only conclusion I can reach is that people are complicated and don’t communicate very well.

Finally, our astronomical nightmare is over

Just when I had given up hope (due to misleading news coverage that suggested the round=planet proposal was a fait accompli), the IAU finally made the right choice regarding Pluto. The additional criterion (missing from an earlier version of the BBC report) is that a planet must have "cleared the neighborhood around its orbit." I had been hoping for requiring that it possess the majority of the mass in its orbital region, but anything that gets us down to the eight bodies with shared origins and finally excludes the Kuiper Belt is okay with me.
My interpretation is that, faced with solid evidence of the absurd results of crafting an objective standard that allowed Pluto to be commonly referred to as a planet (even the proposal separated the 8 "classical" planets from the "plutons" (bizarrely including Ceres)), only the most sentimental of the scientists could bring themselves to support it.